The kitchen table in Martha Wilson’s modest apartment in Tulsa was spread with papers, a calculator, a magnifying glass, and a half-empty cup of tea that had long gone cold. At 73, the retired elementary school teacher had spent her morning doing something she never anticipated would become so complicated: trying to understand exactly how much money she had to live on.
“I got the notice about the cost of living adjustment back in December,” Martha explained, pushing her reading glasses up on her nose as she showed me the official letter. “But now that I’ve gotten my first few adjusted payments, the numbers don’t match what I expected. I’m grateful for any increase, don’t get me wrong, but I need to understand exactly what I’m working with.”
Martha’s confusion is shared by millions of retirees across America who receive Social Security, federal retirement benefits, military pensions, and other retirement income sources that include cost of living adjustments (COLAs). While these annual increases are designed to help seniors maintain their purchasing power as inflation rises, the reality of how they work—and their actual impact on monthly checks—is often misunderstood, leading to budget surprises and financial anxiety.
With the most recent retirement payments hitting accounts on March 12, many seniors are taking a closer look at these adjustments and discovering that the headline COLA percentage doesn’t tell the whole story of what’s happening to their benefits.
The Mechanics Behind Your Changing Benefits
For most retirees, the annual COLA represents a vital financial lifeline, helping benefits at least partially keep pace with rising costs. But the mechanics of how these adjustments are calculated and applied remain a mystery to many recipients.
“I assumed a 3.2% increase meant every part of my benefit went up by exactly that amount,” said Robert Jenkins, a 68-year-old retired postal worker from Charlotte. “Then I got my new benefit statement and realized it’s much more complicated.”
Indeed, the process involves several interlocking components that affect the final amount retirees see in their monthly payments.
How COLA Is Calculated: Not All Inflation Is Created Equal
At its core, the Social Security cost of living adjustment is tied to the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W), a metric that tracks price changes across a basket of common goods and services. The adjustment is based on the third-quarter comparison (July, August, September) from one year to the next.
For 2023, this measurement showed a 3.2% increase, resulting in the corresponding adjustment to Social Security benefits for 2024.
But here’s where the confusion begins: the CPI-W doesn’t necessarily reflect the inflation experienced by seniors.
“Older Americans typically spend more on healthcare and housing than younger working people,” explains Dr. Eleanor Simmons, an economist specializing in retirement policy. “But the CPI-W gives greater weight to transportation, education, and other expenses that feature more prominently in working people’s budgets.”
This discrepancy means that even when benefits adjust by the official inflation rate, many seniors find their personal expenses rising faster than their income.
Martha nodded vigorously when I mentioned this. “My rent went up 5% this year, and my prescription for cholesterol medication increased almost 8%. Meanwhile, my total benefit only went up by that 3.2%. I’m falling behind even with the adjustment.”
When the Increase Actually Hits Your Account
Another source of confusion involves the timing of adjustments. While the COLA for Social Security and most federal retirement programs was announced in October 2023, the actual increased payments didn’t begin until January 2024, with many retirees receiving their first adjusted direct deposits toward the end of January.
For those who receive payments on the regular Social Security schedule (which distributes payments on the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th Wednesdays based on birth dates), this meant waiting until January 10, 17, or 24 to see their increases.
For certain federal retirees, military pension recipients, and others, the March 12 payment represents the third monthly payment reflecting the new COLA-adjusted amounts, providing enough data points for recipients to fully understand their new financial reality.
“I received my third adjusted payment yesterday,” James Rodriguez, a 72-year-old retired Army sergeant in San Antonio, told me during our phone conversation. “Now I can finally see the pattern of what my new normal is going to be for the year.”
The Medicare Premium Effect: Why Your Increase Seems Smaller
Perhaps the single biggest factor creating confusion around COLA adjustments affects the roughly 65 million Americans who have Medicare premiums deducted directly from their Social Security benefits.
For 2024, the standard Medicare Part B premium increased from $164.90 to $174.70 per month—a $9.80 increase that directly reduces the apparent impact of the COLA for millions of seniors.
“When people hear about a 3.2% COLA, they calculate that percentage of their gross benefit and expect to see that exact dollar increase in their payment,” explains William Chen, a financial counselor who specializes in retirement planning. “But if you’re on Medicare with premiums deducted, you need to subtract the Medicare increase to see your actual net gain.”
For Martha, this math made a substantial difference in her budget expectations.
“My gross Social Security benefit is about $2,100 monthly, so I calculated a 3.2% increase would give me about $67 more per month,” she explained, showing me her notebook where she’d worked out the figures. “But after the Medicare premium increase, my actual deposit only went up by about $57. That $10 difference matters when you’re on a fixed income budgeting every dollar.”
For some seniors with lower benefit amounts, the Medicare premium increase can consume a significant portion of their COLA. Consider Sandra Martinez, a 77-year-old widow in Phoenix receiving a below-average benefit of $1,350 monthly.
“My 3.2% increase should have been about $43,” she explained during our call. “But after the Medicare premium went up, I only saw about $33 more in my monthly deposit. That’s almost a quarter of my increase gone just to Medicare.”
Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amounts: The Hidden COLA Reducer
For higher-income retirees, another factor often diminishes the impact of the annual COLA: Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amounts (IRMAA) for Medicare premiums.
Seniors whose modified adjusted gross income exceeds certain thresholds pay substantially more for Medicare Part B and Part D coverage. These thresholds are also subject to annual adjustments, but they don’t always move in perfect alignment with the COLA.
Michael Thompson, a 70-year-old retired executive from Boston, experienced this disconnect firsthand.
“Between my pension and investment income, I fall into one of the IRMAA brackets,” he explained. “What caught me by surprise was that while my Social Security benefit went up by 3.2%, the income threshold for the IRMAA tier only adjusted by about 2%. The result? I’m now paying even more for Medicare because a larger portion of my income exceeds the threshold. My net increase is actually less than half of what the 3.2% COLA suggested.”
For 2024, the IRMAA income thresholds increased from $97,000 to $103,000 for individual filers in the first tier, with corresponding adjustments to other tiers. However, retirees with incomes near these boundaries may find themselves bumped into higher premium categories as their various income sources receive cost of living adjustments.
“It’s a perfect example of how the various parts of the retirement system don’t always work in harmony,” notes Dr. Simmons. “One program gives an adjustment that then triggers a higher cost in another program, reducing the net benefit of the original adjustment.”
Tax Implications: When COLA Pushes You Into Higher Brackets
Beyond Medicare premium effects, cost of living adjustments can trigger another unwelcome surprise: increased tax liability.
Social Security benefits become partially taxable when a recipient’s combined income (adjusted gross income plus nontaxable interest plus half of Social Security benefits) exceeds certain thresholds—$25,000 for individuals or $32,000 for couples filing jointly. These thresholds, unlike many other aspects of the tax code, are not indexed for inflation.
“These tax threshold amounts haven’t changed since 1984,” explains Chen. “As COLA increases gradually push more seniors over these fixed thresholds, an increasing percentage of beneficiaries find themselves paying taxes on their Social Security for the first time.”
Robert Walker, 69, from Omaha, discovered this consequence after last year’s substantial COLA.
“I’d never had to pay tax on my Social Security before,” he told me. “But the 8.7% increase in 2023 pushed me over the threshold. Now I’m paying taxes on 50% of my benefit, which effectively reduced the value of that COLA increase.”
For retirees receiving pensions, the tax situation can be even more complex. While Social Security benefits enjoy special tax treatment (with a maximum of 85% subject to taxation), pension income is generally fully taxable, meaning that every dollar of COLA increase on a pension potentially faces federal and, in many cases, state income tax.
“Many new retirees don’t realize that a $100 increase in monthly pension might only translate to $75-$85 in actual spending power after taxes,” Chen points out. “That’s why accurate budgeting requires understanding the after-tax impact of any COLA.”
The Varying Impact Across Different Retirement Systems
While Social Security’s 3.2% COLA has received the most attention, retirees should understand that different retirement systems apply cost of living adjustments in various ways, creating significant disparities.
Military Retirement System
For military retirees, 2024 brought the same 3.2% COLA as Social Security recipients. However, the timing and application differ slightly. Military retirement pay adjustments take effect on December 31, meaning retired service members saw their increase in their January payments.
James Rodriguez, the retired Army sergeant, noted an additional complexity: “Different military retirement systems have different COLA applications. I’m under the Final Pay system, so I get the full COLA. But friends who retired under Redux receive reduced COLAs, getting 1% less than the announced rate.”
Federal Employee Retirement System (FERS) vs. Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS)
Federal retirees face perhaps the most complex COLA situation, with adjustments varying based on when they retired and under which system.
CSRS retirees receive the full COLA (3.2% for 2024), identical to Social Security recipients. However, FERS retirees often receive reduced adjustments. If the COLA is below 2%, FERS retirees get the full amount; if it’s between 2% and 3%, they receive 2%; and if it’s above 3% (as in 2024), they get the COLA minus 1% (so 2.2% for 2024).
Margaret Johnson, a 74-year-old retired federal employee in Atlanta, explained how this affected her.
“I retired under FERS, so instead of the 3.2% everyone talks about, my pension only increased by 2.2%. That’s a significant difference when you calculate it across the year—about $600 less than if I’d gotten the full adjustment.”
State and Local Government Pensions
Perhaps the greatest COLA variations occur among state and local government pension systems, where adjustments range from automatic full inflation protection to no guaranteed increases whatsoever.
Thomas Martinez, a 70-year-old retired teacher from Illinois, faces a fixed 3% annual increase regardless of actual inflation.
“When inflation was low, our fixed 3% seemed generous,” he noted. “But during last year’s high inflation, we fell behind. This year, with inflation at 3.2%, we’re close to keeping pace, but still slightly behind. Over time, these small differences compound.”
By contrast, certain states, including Colorado, Kentucky, and Minnesota, have implemented COLA caps or eliminated guaranteed adjustments entirely for some pension plans, leaving retirees especially vulnerable to inflation’s effects.
“I receive no guaranteed COLA at all,” shared Lisa Thompson, a 68-year-old retired county employee from Kentucky. “Any adjustment requires specific legislative action. The last increase we received was 1.5% in 2022, despite double-digit inflation that year. You can imagine how that’s affected my purchasing power.”
Strategic Planning: Maximizing Your COLA’s Impact
Given these complexities, financial advisors recommend several strategies to help retirees maximize the value of their cost of living adjustments and maintain purchasing power.
1. Reconsider Tax Withholding
Since COLA increases can push retirees into higher tax brackets or above thresholds for Social Security taxation, reviewing and potentially adjusting tax withholding makes sense.
“I review my withholding every January after the COLA takes effect,” explains Michael Thompson, the retired executive. “Some years I need to increase withholding to avoid an unexpected tax bill. Other years I can adjust to optimize my cash flow through the year.”
2. Evaluate Medicare Coverage Options
For retirees significantly impacted by Medicare premium increases, exploring alternatives to traditional Medicare might yield savings.
“I switched to a Medicare Advantage plan two years ago,” shared Sandra Martinez. “My particular plan has a zero-dollar premium beyond the standard Part B amount, which means more of my COLA actually stays in my pocket rather than going to supplemental coverage.”
While Medicare Advantage plans aren’t right for everyone, the annual COLA season provides a good opportunity to review healthcare coverage and costs.
3. Adjust Spending Patterns to Match Inflation Realities
Since the official COLA often doesn’t match seniors’ actual experienced inflation, many retirees strategically adjust their spending patterns.
“I’ve become much more intentional about where I spend,” explains Martha. “I track which expenses in my budget are rising faster than my benefits and look for alternatives. For instance, when my favorite grocery items get too expensive, I’ve learned to find substitutes or wait for sales.”
This category-specific approach to inflation management helps retirees maintain purchasing power where it matters most to their quality of life.
4. Consider Part-Time Work to Bridge Gaps
For younger retirees especially, part-time work can provide an important buffer against the erosion of purchasing power when COLAs don’t keep pace with real-world expenses.
“I drive for a rideshare service about 10 hours a week,” says Robert Jenkins, the retired postal worker. “The flexible hours let me work when I want, and the extra income helps cover the gap between what my COLA provides and what inflation actually costs me.”
5. Advocate for Policy Improvements
Finally, many seniors find that collective advocacy helps address structural issues with the COLA system. Organizations like AARP, the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, and various pension-focused groups actively work to improve how retirement benefits maintain value over time.
“I write to my representatives every year about changing how the COLA is calculated,” Martha told me, showing me copies of her most recent letters. “I think we need a Consumer Price Index for the Elderly that better reflects our actual expenses. Individual advocacy may seem small, but together, our voices matter.”
Looking Ahead: The Future of Retirement COLAs
As retirees adjust to the 2024 COLA and its impact on their March 12 payments, many are already wondering what next year might bring.
Early projections suggest the 2025 COLA could be lower than the current 3.2%, potentially in the 2.5-3% range if current inflation trends continue. This would represent a substantial decrease from the 8.7% adjustment in 2023 but would still exceed the average 2.6% COLA over the past 20 years.
“Inflation forecasting is notoriously difficult,” cautions Dr. Simmons. “Global events, energy prices, and policy decisions can quickly change the trajectory. Retirees should prepare for various scenarios rather than counting on specific COLA percentages.”
For Martha Wilson, this uncertainty reinforces her commitment to careful financial management. As we concluded our conversation, she methodically returned her benefit documents to their folder and updated her budget spreadsheet with the latest figures.
“When you live on a fixed income that only adjusts once a year, you learn to be adaptable,” she reflected. “I’m grateful for the COLA—without it, we’d fall further behind every year. But I’ve learned not to take the headlines at face value. The real impact on my daily life is always more complicated than a simple percentage.”
As millions of retirees receive their March 12 payments reflecting this year’s adjustments, Martha’s measured perspective offers valuable wisdom. Cost of living adjustments provide essential protection against inflation’s erosive effects, but understanding their true impact requires looking beyond the headlines to the complex reality of how these adjustments actually affect the money reaching retirees’ bank accounts—and the purchasing power it represents in an ever-changing economy.
Also Read –
Nothing Phone 3a launched in Australian market with price of $599 AUD